The Controversial Killing of Malik bin Nuwayrah: Historical Perspectives

The incident involving Malik bin Nuwayrah, a companion of Prophet Muhammad, and his killing by Khalid ibn al-Walid is a contentious topic within Islamic history. Following the Prophet's death, some tribes, including Malik's, refused to pay zakah to the newly appointed caliph, Abu Bakr, leading to military actions against them. The author argues that Malik and his brother Mutammim were indeed believers, countering claims made by some groups that suggested otherwise. They highlight various historical accounts illustrating Malik's status as a Muslim and a trusted figure during the Prophet's time. The text also discusses Khalid's motives for killing Malik, suggesting it was not justified as Malik was believed to be a practicing Muslim. The aftermath of Malik's death included Khalid marrying Malik's widow, which was controversial and condemned by some, including Umar ibn al-Khattab. The author emphasizes the complexity of the situation, arguing against the notion that Malik was an apostate.