The Depth of Language: A Critique of Modern Dictionaries
Using a dictionary is often seen as a simple task, primarily for looking up unfamiliar words. However, the author argues that many modern dictionaries, including popular ones like the New Oxford American Dictionary and Merriam-Webster, lack depth and vibrancy in their definitions. This leads to a reduced appreciation for language, making it feel mechanical and uninspired. In contrast, John McPhee, a celebrated writer, utilizes a more enriching dictionary that offers nuanced definitions and celebrates the beauty of words. The piece also highlights Noah Webster’s contribution to American English, emphasizing that his dictionary was crafted with care, providing readers with a richer understanding of words. The author expresses a desire to find and use a dictionary that honors the subtleties and richness of language, contrasting it with the mundane alternatives available today.
What is the main criticism of modern dictionaries according to the author?
Modern dictionaries are criticized for their dry, uninspired definitions that lack depth and fail to celebrate the richness of language.
How does John McPhee use dictionaries differently than most people?
John McPhee uses dictionaries to explore words he already knows, seeking nuanced definitions that enhance his writing, rather than just looking up unfamiliar terms.
What was Noah Webster's contribution to American English?
Noah Webster is credited with creating a comprehensive dictionary that defined American English, aiming to capture the language of the new republic and providing a linguistic education through his works.